(C) 2011 František Krahulec. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
For reference, use of the paginated PDF or printed version of this article is recommended.
Within a population of invasive Hieracium pilosella in Chilean Patagonia we found two ploidy levels, pentaploid and hexaploid. Each ploidy level was represented by one clone. Their reproductive system was apomictic (and thus replicating the maternal genome), with a low degree of residual sexuality. It is necessary to prevent the evolution of new biotypes via hybridisation with different clones of Hieracium pilosella or other Hieracium species introduced into Patagonia.
Hieracium pilosella, Patagonia, ploidy levels, hybridisation
In 2010, a paper on a Hieracium pilosella invasion in Patagonia (Tierra del Fuego, Argentina) was published by
Hieracium pilosella (syn. Pilosella officinarum) consists of several ploidy races (cytotypes), which combine with different reproductive modes (reviewed in
Many species of the Hieracium subgen. Pilosella are facultatively apomictic, producing predominantly progeny, which is genetically identical with their maternal parent. Nevertheless, a (usually minor) proportion of their progeny are formed by sexual process. The degree of this residual sexuality varies among species and is generally unknown, having not been studied thoroughly (for the quantification of residual sexuality in three species, see
In 2005, we acquired seeds from Hieracium pilosella plants (and other subgen. Pilosella species) collected in Chilean Patagonia. Based on the collector’s information on the highly extensive populations of Hieracium pilosella in this area, we presumed that this species was reproducing apomictically. Therefore, we cultivated mature plants from seeds sampled in the field, and we determined their ploidy level and reproductive mode. Our data, which are complementary to those in a recently published paper (
In the summer of 2004/2005, Ladislava Filipová collected herbarium specimens of Hieracium pilosella with seeds from the following localities:
Loc. 1. Patagonia, Kampenaike, Punta Arenas, Cerro Caballo; 52°43'02"S, 70°57'46"W, alt. 30 m (4 plants).
Loc. 2. Patagonia, Kampenaike, Punta Arenas, Gali 2; 52°42'27"S, 70°59'48"W, alt. 29 m (3 plants).
Loc. 3. Patagonia, Kampenaike, N margin of Punta Arenas, Domaike, 53°7'24"S, 70°52'14"W, alt. 4 m (2 plants).
The seeds were extracted from pressed fruiting plants and were sown in 2005 into pots with sterilised garden soil. Later, the seedlings were replanted, and the mature plants were kept in outdoor beds in an experimental garden at the Institute of Botany at Průhonice, the Czech Republic. Specimens of the plants sampled in the field and of the plants cultivated from their seeds are deposited in the herbarium of the Institute of Botany, Průhonice, the Czech Republic (PRA).
Ploidy level and reproductive mode were determined using standard methods and following the procedures described by
The clonal (or genotypic) identity of the material from different localities was determined by comparing the isozyme phenotypes of the respective cultivated plants; a combination of four enzymes (AAT, EST, LAP, PGM) was used because this system has sufficient resolution efficiency in Hieracium subgen. Pilosella (
A total of 57 plants were cultivated from seeds that were sampled from nine maternal plants at three localities in Patagonia. All 25 cultivated progeny plants originating from the four maternal plants at locality 1 (Materials and Methods) were pentaploid. The other progeny plants, originating from both locality 2 (three maternal plants/11 cultivated progeny plants) and locality 3 (two maternal plants/21 cultivated progeny plants), were hexaploid. All of the progeny plants were apomictic, and their morphology was highly uniform within each cytotype: this fact implied an apomictic reproductive mode in the maternal plants collected in the field. For this reason, to detect the clonal structure among their presumably apomictic maternal parents, we chose only one progeny plant from each maternal array for isozyme analysis. Analysis showed that each cytotype was composed of only a single clone. Thus, the pentaploids and hexaploids were found to be clonally uniform. These two clones differed also in their cp-DNA haplotypes. The hexaploid clone had the main group II haplotype (namely subtype II/7), which predominates in Hieracium pilosella in Europe (
The level of residual sexuality was low in both the pentaploid and hexaploid apomictic clones. A total of 30 progeny seeds produced by the pentaploid clone pollinated by tetraploid Hieracium pilosella were analysed using the FCSS method (two seeds were analysed per sample). All of these seeds (100%) had pentaploid embryos and decaploid endosperm, corresponding to autonomous apomixis giving rise to pentaploid apomictic progeny. FCSS analysis of 190 progeny seeds showed that crossing the hexaploid clone with tetraploid Hieracium pilosella also generated predominantly apomictic progeny. In the respective flow cytometric histograms (10 seeds were analysed per sample), 189 hexaploid embryos were recorded in total; a clearly detectable small peak of apomictic dodecaploid endosperm was present in all of the histograms, which again corresponds to autonomous apomixis. Only one octoploid embryo (out of 190 embryos analysed) originated from the hexaploid × tetraploid cross, likely originating from an unreduced female gamete of the hexaploid maternal plant being fertilised by a diploid male gamete of the tetraploid pollen parent. Consequently, the frequency of apomixis in hexaploid apomictic Hieracium pilosella was estimated to be 99.5%.
DiscussionAt all three ploidy levels that are most common in Hieracium pilosella, both apomictic and sexual plants are known. Nevertheless, most of the data on chromosome number and reproductive system are based on plants from its native distribution area in Europe. The plants invading New Zealand are mostly pentaploid and apomictic, although tetraploids and hexaploids have been found there rarely (
Species of Hieracium subgen. Pilosella are known as easily hybridising, forming both stabilised hybrids (hybridogenous species) and hybrid swarms, even between different ploidy levels (e.g.,
The following measures are recommended to prevent the rapid evolution of new biotypes of Hieracium pilosella (and its hybrids) in Patagonia: (i) prevent the introduction of both new clones and new cytotypes of Hieracium pilosella, as well as of new species of the Pilosella subgenus (ii) look for possible hybrids among introduced Hieracium species and (iii) eradicate these hybrids from sites where they currently occur.
We thank Ladislava Filipová (Ústí nad Labem) for collecting Hieracium seeds and herbarium specimens. Ivana Plačková (Průhonice) is acknowledged for performing the isozyme analysis. This study was supported by the Czech Science Foundation (project no. 206/08/0890) and by a long-term institutional research plan (AVOZ60050516) from the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic.