Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Diana M. F. Borse ( diana.borse@auckland.ac.nz ) Academic editor: Moritz von der Lippe
© 2026 Diana M. F. Borse, Angela J. Brandt, Nick Waipara, Margaret C. Stanley.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Borse DMF, Brandt AJ, Waipara N, Stanley MC (2026) Weed co-occurrence patterns in revegetation plantings: Implications for managing multiple weed species. NeoBiota 110: 43-64. https://doi.org/10.3897/neobiota.110.185632
|
Most weed research has focused on single species, whereas managers of conservation habitats often deal with multiple co-occurring species. Effective multi-weed management in revegetation plantings is crucial to prevent unintended responses to the removal of single species, which can change the successional trajectory of the planting project. Predicting positive and negative weed associations can help managers prioritise weed removal to prevent unintended responses from co-occurring weeds. Seedling plots were used to identify species co-occurring under each of three target woody weeds in revegetation plantings in Auckland, Aotearoa – New Zealand (Solanum mauritianum, Paraserianthes lophantha, and Ligustrum lucidum) and compare them with seedlings growing under native plants. Twenty-four pairs of weed species were significantly correlated with each other’s occurrence, either positively (often found together) or negatively (rarely found together). Mature, shade-tolerant L. lucidum was significantly correlated (both positively and negatively) with the most weed species (n = 9). Nitrogen-fixing P. lophantha had one positive and one negative pairwise association with other weed species, while allelopathic S. mauritianum had two negative associations. Shared bird dispersal and shade tolerance were associated with an increased probability of co-occurrence for seedlings. While bird-dispersed seedlings arrive at the site together, their associations are subsequently shaped by interspecific interactions, such as competition and facilitation. Higher housing density, resident native species richness, and vascular vegetation cover were all associated with higher weed richness, whereas higher human population density was associated with lower weed richness. Woody weeds, particularly shade-tolerant and bird-dispersed species, should be prioritised by managers of urban revegetation projects.
Co-occurrence, environmental weeds, invasion, management, New Zealand, restoration, species interactions
Environmental weeds (hereafter referred to as ‘weeds’) are invasive non-native plants that spread rapidly and have negative impacts on native species biodiversity and ecosystem functions (
Conservation management decisions are currently made based on assessments of individual weed species’ impacts due to a lack of understanding of the interactions among co-occurring weeds and how these interactions shape the impacts these weeds have on native species (
Revegetation plantings are composed of newly planted vegetation that has not formed a dense canopy and is therefore vulnerable to weed invasion. These plantings are particularly vulnerable where they are adjacent to human settlements. Urban areas can be biodiversity hotspots, particularly in regions with high endemism (
Co-occurrence patterns among weeds in urban revegetation plantings were investigated by comparing weeds co-occurring in plots centred around a target weed, one of three highly invasive woody species of relevance to conservation managers (woolly nightshade, Solanum mauritianum; tree privet, Ligustrum lucidum; and brush wattle, Paraserianthes lophantha), paired with a plot centred around a native tree to assess whether differences were simply a function of the site. These weeds were selected because they are widespread, under regional regulatory management in Aotearoa (
Survey plots were located in revegetation plantings on public land and in native species plantings on smaller blocks of private land in the Auckland region of Aotearoa. Auckland is a coastal city positioned on an isthmus, with a subtropical climate and 1.797 million residents (
To assess the differences in plant assemblages growing with each target weed, a total of 162 plots were sampled, with 27 centred around each of the three target weed species (n = 81 weed-centred plots), each paired with a native tree-centred plot to assess whether differences were simply a function of the site (Suppl. material
Temporary 4 m2 circular plots were established by placing a peg with a 1.13 m string attached at the base of the central individual (weed or native) and circumscribing an area of 4 m2. Attribute data were collected for each plot, including canopy and ground cover, slope, height and DBH of the central individual, and presence of disturbance (e.g. footpaths, fences, dumped refuse) within the plot. Three forest canopy density measurements taken from three points equidistant from the central individual, with a random starting point, were averaged using a spherical densitometer at 30 cm above ground level to capture cover at seedling height. Vascular plant cover was estimated as the percentage of the ground area within the plot covered by vascular plants. Housing density within 250 m was determined by counting houses using Google Earth with satellite imagery from 31 December 2020. Human population density for the statistical reporting areas (defined by the government census in Aotearoa) around each site in 1996 and 2023 and the number of dwellings in 2023 were sourced from StatsNZ (
All individual plants taller than 5 cm within each plot were identified and categorised by height tier to determine the number of individuals per species in each height category. Height tiers of < 15 cm, 15–50 cm, 50–150 cm, and > 150 cm were used, following standard vegetation survey methods in Aotearoa (
All analyses were performed using the R programming language (
The probability of co-occurrence and positive and negative relationships between the 15 most common weeds in all plots (S. mauritianum, L. lucidum, P. lophantha, and native-centred plots) were analysed using Veech’s probabilistic model (
To understand which factors most influenced environmental weed species richness, a model selection process (
Overall, the proportion of native species in the seedling stage did not vary between weed- and native-centred plots (ANOVA: F = 1.8, p > 0.1, Fig.
The proportion of seedlings that are native species in plots centred around native species and three target weeds. Data were collected in revegetation plantings in the Auckland region using 4 m2 plots centred around either a native species, Solanum mauritianum, Ligustrum lucidum, or Paraserianthes lophantha (n = 81 native-centred plots, n = 27 plots centred around each target weed). Horizontal lines represent the median values, the bounds of the boxes represent the interquartile range (IQR), notches represent the 95% confidence intervals, and the whiskers represent the largest and smallest data points, respectively, within 1.5× the IQR.
The 10 most common species found as seedlings, ordered from most (top) to least (bottom) common within each plot type, found in plots centred around native trees, Solanum mauritianum, Ligustrum lucidum, and Paraserianthes lophantha in 4 m2 plots in revegetation plantings in Auckland. Native species are in bold, and species included on the Aotearoa environmental weeds list (
| Native species | S. mauritianum | L. lucidum | P. lophantha |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coprosma robusta (T) 8.3% | Solanum mauritianum *(T) 9.7% | Coprosma robusta (T) 9.5% | Coprosma robusta (T) 11.9% |
| Ligustrum sinense * (T) 5.1% | Coprosma robusta (T) 8.0% | Ligustrum sinense *(T) 8.1% | Paraserianthes lophantha *(T) 5.9% |
| Tradescantia fluminensis *(F) 3.8% | Ranunculus repens (F) 5.3% | Ligustrum lucidum *(T) 6.1% | Ligustrum lucidum *(T) 5.0% |
| Ligustrum lucidum *(T) 3.5% | Tradescantia fluminensis *(F) 5.3% | Tradescantia fluminensis *(F) 5.4% | Lophomyrtus obcordate (S) 5.0% |
| Zantedeschia aethiopica *(F) 2.3% | Calystegia silvatica *(V) 2.7% | Lonicera japonica *(V) 4.1% | Pittosporum crassifolium (T) 5.0% |
| Asparagus scandens *(V) 2.0 | Melicytus ramiflorus (T) 2.65% | Podocarpus totara (T) 4.1% | Solanum mauritianum *(T) 4.0% |
| Myrsine australis (T) 2.5% | Smilax asparagoides *(V) 1.8% | Zantedeschia aethiopica *(F) | Tradescantia fluminensis *(F) 4.0% |
| Ranunculus repens (F) 2.5% | Hedychium gardnerianum *(F) 1.8% | Alectryon excelsus (T) 3.4% | Alectryon excelsus (T) 3.0% |
| Solanum mauritianum *(T) 2.5% | Onopordum acanthium (F) 1.8% | Asparagus scandens *(V) 3.4% | Araujia sericifera *(V) |
| Corynocarpus laevigatus (T) 2.3% | Araujia sericifera *(V) 1.8% | Galium aparine (F) 3.4% | Asparagus scandens *(V) 3.0% |
Weed seedling composition differed significantly between S. mauritianum- and L. lucidum-centred plots, with S. mauritianum plots having higher values in dimension 2 (Fig.
NMDS of weed seedling composition data collected in revegetation plantings in the Auckland region using 4 m2 plots centred around either Solanum mauritianum, Ligustrum lucidum, or Paraserianthes lophantha (n = 81 plots).
SIMPER analysis showed that nine to 11 species in each combination of plot types contributed to up to 80% of the compositional differences (Table
SIMPER results showing the top 12 species contributing to up to 80% of the pairwise compositional differences between Solanum mauritianum-, Ligustrum lucidum-, and Paraserianthes lophantha-centred plots in terms of the mean number of seedlings per plot centred around individuals of each species.
| Species | Mean number of seedlings | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| S. mauritianum plots | L. lucidum plots | P. lophantha plots | |
| Ligustrum sinense | 0.38 | 1.25 | 0.47 |
| Tradescantia fluminensis | 0.96 | 0.67 | 0.39 |
| Ligustrum lucidum | 0.11 | 0.91 | 0.39 |
| Solanum mauritianum | 0.96 | 0.00 | 0.21 |
| Lonicera japonica | 0.00 | 0.72 | 0.21 |
| Paraserianthes lophantha | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.72 |
| Zantedeschia aethiopica | 0.07 | 0.21 | 0.00 |
| Araujia sericifera | 0.07 | 0.20 | 0.26 |
| Smilax asparagoides | 0.30 | 0.04 | 0.00 |
| Calystegia silvatica | 0.16 | 0.17 | 0.61 |
| Asparagus scandens | 0.74 | 0.08 | 0.35 |
| Hedychium gardnerianum | 0.15 | 0.18 | 0.00 |
Analysis of probabilistic co-occurrence relationships between weeds showed that weeds have distinct co-occurrence patterns (Fig.
The probability of co-occurrence among the 15 most common weeds of all heights (A) and among seedlings (B) found in 4 m2 vegetation plots centred around Solanum mauritianum, Ligustrum lucidum, Paraserianthes lophantha, and various native species in revegetation plantings across the Auckland region. The central individuals of each plot were not included in the correlation matrix. Pairings with positive probabilities of co-occurrence (p < 0.05) are shown in teal, pairings with negative probabilities of co-occurrence (p < 0.05) are shown in magenta, and non-significant relationship probabilities are shown in grey. Species that have bird-dispersed seeds are shown in bold.
For seedlings, there were seven significant associations among the 225 weed species pairs (0.3%), with two positive correlations (28.5%) and five negative correlations (71.5%; Fig.
For both native and non-native seedlings, pairs that included bird-dispersed species were more likely to co-occur than not, and this probability appeared to increase as the number of bird-dispersed species in the pair increased from zero to one and from one to two (Fig.
The associations between the probability of co-occurrence and the number of species in a pair that were bird-dispersed (A, B) and shade-tolerant (C, D) for native and non-native seedlings in revegetation plantings in the Auckland region using 4 m2 vegetation plots centred around either native species, Solanum mauritianum, Ligustrum lucidum, or Paraserianthes lophantha. The probability of any co-occurrence increased as the number of bird-dispersed species in the pair increased from neither to both species being bird-dispersed (A), and the magnitude of co-occurrence probability among species that did co-occur did not differ between pairs with neither, one, or both bird-dispersed species (B). The probability of any co-occurrence increased as the number of shade-tolerant species in the pair increased from neither to both species being shade-tolerant (C), and the magnitude of co-occurrence probability among species that did co-occur did not differ between pairs with neither, one, or both shade-tolerant species (D).
Model selection yielded a model for predicting weed seedling richness in the revegetation plots that included the number of houses within 250 m of the site, vascular plant cover, resident native species richness, and site (AICc = 701.5, Tables 3, Suppl. material
Effects plots of model-selected factors influencing weed seedling richness in revegetation plantings in the Auckland region using 4 m2 vegetation plots centred around either native species, Solanum mauritianum, Ligustrum lucidum, or Paraserianthes lophantha. The number of houses within 250 m of a site (A), the richness of resident native species in the plot (B), the percentage of vascular plant cover in the plot (C), and the human population density of the area in 1996 (D) all predicted weed seedling richness.
Model selection results with the following factors: height of the central individual, central individual DBH, slope and canopy cover of the plot, site (as a random factor), the percentage of the plot covered by vascular plants, presence of disturbance in the plot, the richness of resident native species in the plot, the richness of resident weed species in the plot, the number of houses within 250 m of the site, and the human population density of the statistical reporting area in 1996 and 2023. Factors were reduced by determining multicollinearity among variables using variance inflation factors. The model outputs with ΔAICc < 2 are included in the table below.
| Dependent variable: | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Response variable | ||||||||||||
| Model 1 | Model 2 | Model 3 | Model 4 | Model 5 | Model 6 | Model 7 | Model 8 | Model 9 | Model 10 | Model 11 | Model 12 | |
| Height of central individual | –0.014 | |||||||||||
| (0.023) | ||||||||||||
| Disturbance | -0.042 | |||||||||||
| (0.083) | ||||||||||||
| Canopy cover | 0.002 | |||||||||||
| (0.004) | ||||||||||||
| Houses within 250 m | 0.003*** | 0.003*** | 0.003*** | 0.003*** | 0.002*** | 0.003*** | 0.002*** | 0.003*** | 0.003*** | 0.003*** | 0.003*** | 0.003*** |
| (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.001) | |
| Population density 2023 | 0.00004 | 0.00005 | ||||||||||
| (0.0001) | (0.00005) | |||||||||||
| Population density 1996 | –0.0001** | –0.0001** | –0.0001* | –0.0001** | –0.0001** | –0.0001** | –0.0001** | –0.0001* | –0.0001** | –0.0001** | ||
| (0.00004) | (0.00004) | (0.00004) | (0.00004) | (0.00004) | (0.00004) | (0.00004) | (0.00004) | (0.00004) | (0.00004) | |||
| Richness of resident natives | 0.102*** | 0.099*** | 0.101*** | 0.097*** | 0.104*** | 0.103*** | 0.103*** | 0.101*** | 0.105*** | 0.102*** | 0.100*** | 0.102*** |
| (0.026) | (0.025) | (0.026) | (0.025) | (0.026) | (0.026) | (0.026) | (0.026) | (0.026) | (0.026) | (0.026) | (0.026) | |
| Richness of resident weeds | 0.040 | 0.045 | 0.043 | |||||||||
| (0.032) | (0.032) | (0.032) | ||||||||||
| Slope | 0.002 | |||||||||||
| (0.003) | ||||||||||||
| Vascular plant cover | 0.005*** | 0.005*** | 0.005*** | 0.005*** | 0.004** | 0.004*** | 0.004** | 0.005*** | 0.005*** | 0.004*** | 0.004*** | 0.005*** |
| (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | (0.002) | |
| Weed or native status central individual | -0.090 | -0.102 | -0.091 | |||||||||
| (0.073) | (0.074) | (0.073) | ||||||||||
| Constant | 0.932*** | 0.890*** | 1.064*** | 1.035*** | 0.909*** | 0.907*** | 1.041*** | 0.910*** | 0.974*** | 0.951*** | 0.861*** | 0.783** |
| (0.114) | (0.117) | (0.156) | (0.157) | (0.122) | (0.118) | (0.161) | (0.119) | (0.131) | (0.120) | (0.122) | (0.343) | |
| AICc | 701.061 | 701.657 | 701.748 | 701.978 | 702.228 | 702.583 | 702.852 | 702.866 | 702.898 | 702.993 | 703.032 | 703.036 |
| ΔAICc | 0 | 0.596 | 0.687 | 0.917 | 1.167 | 1.522 | 1.792 | 1.805 | 1.837 | 1.932 | 1.971 | 1.975 |
| Weight | 0.116 | 0.086 | 0.082 | 0.073 | 0.065 | 0.054 | 0.047 | 0.047 | 0.046 | 0.044 | 0.043 | 0.043 |
| Observations | 160 | 160 | 160 | 160 | 160 | 160 | 160 | 160 | 160 | 160 | 160 | 160 |
| Log likelihood | –344.256 | –343.460 | –343.506 | –342.512 | –345.919 | –343.923 | –345.152 | –344.064 | –344.081 | –344.128 | –343.039 | –344.150 |
| Akaike inf. crit. | 700.512 | 700.920 | 701.011 | 701.024 | 701.838 | 701.846 | 702.303 | 702.129 | 702.161 | 702.256 | 702.078 | 702.299 |
| Bayesian inf. crit. | 718.963 | 722.446 | 722.537 | 725.626 | 717.214 | 723.373 | 720.754 | 723.655 | 723.687 | 723.783 | 726.680 | 723.825 |
| Note: | *p**p***p < 0.01 | |||||||||||
Overall, the study found high weed richness, varying from four to 12 weed species in each plot across the sites and beneath different target weed and native species. This is a high number of weeds considering the small size of the sampled areas and that each additional weed species can substantially impact native plantings. Ligustrum lucidum was a key weed species with numerous significant associations, including several positive associations with high-impact environmental weeds, particularly vines, such as Araujia sericifera and Smilax asparagoides, suggesting that this weed should be a high priority for managers (
The most common seedling species in all plot types were weeds. The plots that had the highest number of common native seedlings were those centred around P. lophantha. Based on the nitrogen-fixing capacity of P. lophantha, its presence was expected to be associated with an increased abundance and impact of weed species rather than early successional native species adapted to low nutrient levels (
The composition of weed seedlings differed among the three target weed plot types, especially between S. mauritianum- and L. lucidum-centred plots. Conspecific seedlings were major contributors to the differences between each of the weed plot types, potentially indicating either an intraspecific nurse plant effect (
Co-occurrence associations among weeds were mostly negative, but approximately a third were positive, suggesting that common weeds may be capable of both facilitating and inhibiting the establishment of other weeds (
To understand positive and negative relationships, it is necessary to determine whether species co-occur more often than expected by chance after accounting for environmental filtering (
Several vines were positively associated with shade-tolerant L. lucidum seedlings, but most were not found commonly in L. lucidum-centred plots. Asparagus scandens, Araujia sericifera, C. sylvatica, and Lonicera japonica were all positively associated with L. lucidum. It is not clear from this study, with few shade-tolerant woody weed species recorded, whether this is a relationship specific to L. lucidum or whether other shade-tolerant woody weeds (e.g. Prunus campanulata or Syzygium smithii) have the same type of association with vines. This relationship may be due to vines’ ability to climb and outcompete plants with other growth habits in low-light environments. However, if this were the case, more of these vine species would be expected to be common in L. lucidum-centred plots, rather than only L. japonica. A more plausible explanation may be that, as a shade-tolerant weed, L. lucidum can successfully grow beneath resident vines more often than other woody species that are shaded out, such as S. mauritianum and P. lophantha (
Understanding the role of plant traits in interspecific associations could help optimise management priorities by accounting for facilitation between environmental weeds. In this study, bird-dispersed seeds and shade tolerance appeared to be associated with an increased probability of co-occurrence. Allelopathy, on the other hand, was not associated with either positive or negative associations. Nitrogen-fixing ability has been predicted to be associated with the facilitation of weeds (
Weed seedling richness did not differ between native-centred and weed-centred plots but increased with higher numbers of resident native plants in the plot and greater vascular plant cover. Therefore, it appears that the identity of a single central individual did not affect weed species establishment as much as the overall richness of resident native species in the plot. While resident weed richness did not predict weed seedling richness, many weed seedlings were commonly found under each of the three target weeds. Conspecifics made up a large proportion of these seedlings, indicating that these target weeds are more likely to replace themselves than be replaced by native species (
Weed seedling richness did not vary based on the plot’s central target weed species. One possible explanation is that the plot’s environmental context masked any effect of the central weed species. For example, if P. lophantha tends to establish where available nitrogen is low, then its presence may raise nitrogen levels to those in plots centred around other target species, or nitrogen levels may have been high in all plots due to high runoff in this urban area, such that nitrogen fixation by P. lophantha would not have a biologically significant impact. However, the most parsimonious explanation is that high weed propagule pressure from factors such as high housing density overwhelmed these finer-scale factors that could influence seedling establishment. Most of the plant species observed are dispersed by birds, consistent with previous work assessing revegetation plantings in Aotearoa (
There was also a relationship between weed seedling richness and housing density and 1996 human population density. Weed species richness increased with an increase in the number of houses around the site. Due to the gardens associated with residential houses, there is greater potential for propagule pressure from ornamental weeds (
The results indicate that active management of revegetation plantings is important in areas with higher native species richness due to the increased pressure from multiple weed species. Rather than offering biotic resistance, highly species-rich native plantings in urban environments appear to be favoured by birds, which can disperse predominantly weed seeds to these sites. To ensure that restoration goals are met, removal of shade-tolerant woody weeds and vines should be prioritised to give native species a competitive advantage.
Finding several positive associations was unexpected given the bias in the literature towards studying competition among weeds. While considerable variation was found in pairwise associations between species, certain species might be especially likely to form positive associations. Based on the results, Ligustrum lucidum is one such species, and this might be due to its key trait (shade tolerance), which makes it highly tolerant of competition from other species, or it may facilitate the growth of surrounding weeds, although other factors may be involved. This is a pattern that warrants further investigation – for example, whether it is a general trend for shade-tolerant species and whether L. lucidum is the driver or passenger in the association. Ligustrum lucidum already presents a high risk in terms of its impact but is an especially high-risk species given that it may be associated with an increase in co-occurring weed species. This risk is especially great given that an increased number of weed species was associated with greater vascular plant cover, which can suppress native species regeneration. As a widespread species in Aotearoa, site-led control of L. lucidum to prevent the establishment of both L. lucidum seedlings and co-occurring high-risk weeds in revegetation plantings may be prudent. Site-led control can be accompanied by investment in biocontrol measures such as the work currently underway on the biocontrol of its congener Ligustrum sinense using Leptoypha hospita (lace bug) (
Higher-density housing solutions in urban areas such as Auckland may limit the spread of new weed species from increased human settlement. Unlike housing developments in the past, which included personal gardens, newer builds with apartment-style or multi-unit buildings introduce fewer opportunities for ornamental species to escape and establish as weeds in the surrounding areas. However, prevention, such as encouraging the planting of native or non-weedy non-native species, is vital for improving the success of restoring native species cover in urban areas.
The authors would like to thank the property owners and Auckland Council staff who gave permission to access and conduct this research on their land. Thanks to Bella Perham, Ella Speers, Arwen Barendregt, Sandra Anderson, Allan Wu, Julianne Gaviraghi Mussoi, and Kamya Patel for their assistance in conducting field surveys.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
The authors accept full responsibility for the content of the manuscript, including the disclosure of any use of AI.
During programming, Microsoft Copilot was used to assist with generating R-code. The generated code was manually reviewed, optimized, and validated by the authors to ensure correct data execution and formatting. No scientific interpretations or claims were made by the AI software.
This work was supported by the University of Auckland and Bioprotection Aotearoa.
Conceptialisation, Methodology: All. Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Project administration, Software, Visualisation, Writing – original draft; DMFB; Supervision, Validation, Writing – review & editing: MCS, AJB, NW; Funding aquisition, Resources: MCS.
D.M.F. Borse https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0084-6930
A.J. Brandt https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5980-9128
N. Waipara https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8193-8302
M.C. Stanley https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0701-8935
Data is available on Figshare: https://doi.org/10.17608/k6.auckland.30842993.
Supplementary information
Data type: docx
Explanation note: table S1. Sites included in the study with area in hectares (Auckland Council Geomaps 2016). table S2. The frequency of plot pairs between native species and weed species as central individuals in order from the most common pairings to the least common. fig. S1. (A) Stress plot for the nMDS of the weed seedlings, stress = 0.081. (B) Goodness of fit for the nMDS of the weed seedlings. (C) The beta dispersion determining whether there is variance in the shape of the dispersions of the nMDS that would account for any differences found in the PERMANOVA.