Research Article |
Corresponding author: Ashlyn L. Padayachee ( ashlyn.levadia@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Ramiro Bustamante
© 2019 Ashlyn L. Padayachee, Şerban Procheş, John R. U. Wilson.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Padayachee AL, Procheş Ş, Wilson JRU (2019) Prioritising potential incursions for contingency planning: pathways, species, and sites in Durban (eThekwini), South Africa as an example. NeoBiota 47: 1-21. https://doi.org/10.3897/neobiota.47.31959
|
Increased trade and travel have resulted in an increasing rate of introduction of biological organisms to new regions. Urban environments, such as cities, are hubs for human activities facilitating the introduction of alien species. Additionally, cities are susceptible to invading organisms as a result of the highly altered and transformed nature of these environments. Despite best efforts at prevention, new incursions of alien species will occur; therefore, prioritising incursion response efforts is essential. This study explores these ideas to identify priorities for strategic prevention planning in a South African city, Durban (eThekwini), by combining data from alien species watch lists, environmental criteria, and the pathways which facilitate the introduction of alien species in the city. Three species (with known adverse impacts elsewhere in the world) were identified as highly likely to be introduced and established in Durban (Alternanthera philoxeroides, Lithobates catesbeianus and Solenopsis invicta). These species are most likely to enter at either the Durban Harbour; pet and aquarium stores; or plant nurseries and garden centres – therefore active surveillance should target these sites as well as adjacent major river systems and infrastructure. We suggest that the integrated approach (species, pathways, and sites) demonstrated in this study will help prioritise resources to detect the most likely and damaging future incursions of alien species.
biological invasions, early detection, incursion response planning, prioritisation, alligator weed, southern sandbur, American bullfrog, red imported fire ant
Human-related activities such as trade and travel have facilitated the increased introduction of biological organisms outside their native range (
Similarly, pathways facilitating the introduction of alien species to new regions need to be identified and the risk associated with introductions facilitated through these pathways assessed. Priority should then be given to the pathways of introduction which pose the highest risk of facilitating the introduction of alien species (
Finally, sites are assessed as high-risk based on the likelihood of an invasion (i.e., the exposure to incursions and whether incursions will establish themselves and become invasions) and sensitivity (i.e., most vulnerable to the impacts of invasions) (
In this study we identify potential future incursions in Durban (eThekwini), South Africa, based on selected alien species, the pathways facilitating their introduction, and the sites most at risk of being invaded by these species. By jointly considering species, pathways, and sites, we aim to provide a tool for decision makers to more effectively target surveillance and contingency planning.
The eThekwini municipality is one of the largest port cities on the east coast of the African continent and is an important economic centre in South Africa (
To develop a methodology for decision makers to assign priorities for prevention strategies we: 1) identified cities with a similar climate to eThekwini; 2) used existing lists of species considered as not present in South Africa that pose an unacceptable risk of invasion; 3) identified which of the selected species are likely to have pathways facilitating their introduction to eThekwini; 4) developed climatic suitability models for the selected species based on the climate in eThekwini; and 5) linked the climate and pathway information to identify sites within eThekwini that should be the focus of contingency planning for particular species (Figure
A simple and rapid method to prioritise targets for contingency planning to prevent biological invasions. The method identifies priority sites for managing particular high-risk incursions. A Shows the selection criteria used to select target species for climatic suitability analyses, with the number of species selected at each stage of selection indicated in parentheses. B Shows the criteria used to identify potential points of introduction for the select target species, as well as the criteria used to identify potential points of naturalisation, i.e. priority sites for monitoring in the eThekwini municipality.
Human population, as a result of the associated activities (trade and travel), is one of the main correlates of species introductions into regions outside of their native range (
The National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act (No. 10 of 2004) governs all biodiversity related issues in South Africa, including biological invasions (NEMBA, 2014). In regulations under NEMBA, a prohibited species list was created, based in part on expert opinion, that lists species that are not believed to be present in South Africa and whose introduction should be prevented (DEA, 2016). The implication is that strategic prevention plans should be developed for all species on the prohibited list. Separate to this,
We used these national lists and applied our own selection criteria (Figure
Maximum entropy distribution modelling was selected to map the potential geographic distribution and evaluate the risk of invasion of the remaining species (Maxent v3.4.1 –
Fifty-nine species were on both the NEMBA prohibited species list and the watch list produced by
We identified the pathways of introduction for each of the remaining species. At this stage, we excluded V. vulpes (red fox) as it is extremely unlikely to be introduced by the only pathways that have historically led to its introduction to other countries (hunting in the wild and fur farms – GISD, 2018). The pathways facilitating the introduction of C. echinatus were unknown (GISD, 2018). This meant that while it was possible to still build a climatic suitability model for the species, it is not possible, at this stage, to link climate suitability to introduction pathways (Box
Pathways of introduction, preferred habitats, potential entry points, sites to monitor, and climatic suitability for Alternanthera philoxeroides (alligator weed).
The climate models developed for the selected species ranged from highly accurate model performance to moderately accurate performance based on the AUC of receiver operating characteristics (see Table
Pathways of introduction, preferred habitats, potential entry points, sites to monitor, and climatic suitability for Cenchrus echinatus (southern sandbur).
Additionally, we superimposed pet and aquarium shops, nurseries and garden centres, the major river systems and the Durban Harbour data with the climatic suitability models (see Boxes
Pathways of introduction, preferred habitats, potential entry points, sites to monitor, and climatic suitability for Lithobates catesbeianus.
pathways of introduction, preferred habitats, potential entry points, sites to monitor, and climatic suitability for Solenopsis invicta.
List of species for which predictive models were developed, the bioclimatic predictors used to develop each model, and the percentage contribution of each predictor to the model.
Species | Bioclimatic Predictors selected (% contribution to model) | Model Performance (AUC ± Standard Deviation) |
---|---|---|
Alternanthera philoxeroides | Mean diurnal range (10), Mean temperature of the warmest month (17), Precipitation seasonality (21), Precipitation of the warmest quarter (9), Precipitation of the coldest quarter (54) | High accuracy (0.929 ± 0.007) |
Cenchrus echinatus | Mean temperature of the warmest quarter (25), Precipitation of seasonality (34), Precipitation of the wettest quarter (44), Precipitation of the driest quarter (7) | Moderate accuracy (0.812 ± 0.008) |
Lithobates catesbeianus | Mean diurnal range (4), Temperature seasonality (44), Maximum temperature of the warmest month (21), Precipitation of the warmest quarter (3), Precipitation of the coldest quarter (38) | Moderate accuracy (0.791 ± 0.005) |
Solenopsis invicta | Mean diurnal range (13), Maximum temperature of the warmest month (28), Precipitation of the wettest month (20), Precipitation of the driest month (45), Precipitation seasonality (4) | High accuracy (0.961 ± 0.006) |
While watch lists and prohibited lists are beneficial in highlighting species to monitor, the lists often consist of numerous species, across a variety of taxa (e.g. the NEMBA prohibited species list – 553 targeted species;
The Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) Aichi Target 9 requires that pathways of introduction be identified and prioritised for management efforts (UNEP, 2011). In this study, we identified likely sites of first naturalisation as priorities for incursion response efforts. We identified three important potential introduction points: the Durban Harbour; pet and aquarium stores; and nursery and garden centres. Each of the species used in this study were linked to one of these potential introduction points. The potential sites of first naturalisation identified in this study were all found to be in close proximity to the Durban harbour and the major river systems in the city, indicating that these sites are important for monitoring efforts.
Identifying the pathways facilitating the introduction of alien species is important for preventing alien species introductions. However, not all pathways of introduction are operational in all cities. By identifying the pathways which facilitate alien species introductions, priorities can be assigned to species with the potential of being introduced to the particular region of interest. In this study we were able to eliminate the species Vulpes vulpes (red fox) because the pathways facilitating its introduction (hunting in the wild and fur farms) are not operational in eThekwini. By contrast, the pathways which facilitate the introduction of C. echinatus are unknown. Therefore, determining if, how, and where the species is likely to be introduced to the city should be a key area for future applied research.
The Durban Harbour was identified as an important potential introduction point as well as a site to monitor for the introduction of A. philoxeroides and S. invicta. The pathways facilitating the introduction of these species are linked to the harbour. Alternanthera philoxeroides is primarily introduced through ship ballast and as a stowaway on ship cargo (
The river systems adjacent to potential point of introduction in the municipality were also identified as important sites to monitor. Alternanthera philoxeroides (
Invasions are, of course, often unpredictable and context dependent. Therefore the prioritisation here should only be one small part of an overall biosecurity strategy (
Even though this study focuses on eThekwini, the procedures used here represent a practical method to assign priorities for preventing the introduction of alien species. The methodology used in this study has merit for assigning priorities to a variety of taxa, such as this study (invertebrates, plants and vertebrates), or single taxa studies. Online databases such as CABI ISC, GBIF, GISD and GRIIS make alien species information required for utilising this methodology readily accessible. The accessibility of information and adaptability of the methodology used in this study makes the protocol feasible. However, there are many ways in which the protocol can be improved. For example, occurrence data sourced from online databases are often plagued with inconsistencies (e.g. validity of location points and taxonomy). The use of expert opinion in determining the validity of these data is a potentially beneficial improvement to this prioritisation tool. The procedures used in this study can further be improved quantitatively through additional analyses which will assess how pathways of introduction contribute to invasiveness (e.g. frequency analysis tests) of the target species as well as the contribution of potential introduction points to invasiveness (e.g. landscape level analysis) of target species. The advantage of the technique presented here is that it focuses on likely known threats and ensures that appropriate measures are put in place to deal with them.
Prioritisation is a fundamental component of effective strategic prevention strategies targeting the introduction of alien species to new regions (
This research was funded by the South African National Department of Environmental Affairs through its funding of the South African National Biodiversity Institute, Biological Invasions Directorate.