Research Article |
Corresponding author: Marek Svitok ( svitok@tuzvo.sk ) Academic editor: Sidinei Magela Thomaz
© 2019 Richard Hrivnák, Jana Medvecká, Peter Baláži, Kateřina Bubíková, Helena Oťaheľová, Marek Svitok.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Hrivnák R, Medvecká J, Baláži P, Bubíková K, Oťaheľová H, Svitok M (2019) Alien aquatic plants in Slovakia over 130 years: historical overview, current distribution and future perspectives. NeoBiota 49: 37-56. https://doi.org/10.3897/neobiota.49.34318
|
Alien aquatic plants rank amongst the major threats to aquatic biodiversity and, since ongoing climate change is expected to facilitate their further spread, there is an urgent need for sound knowledge of their distribution and ecology. We collected published and unpublished data spanning the last ~130 years and performed the first comprehensive assessment of alien aquatic vascular plants in Slovakia with the following aims: (i) to prepare a national inventory, (ii) to assess the effects of climate and landscape on species diversity and (iii) to evaluate the habitat preferences of the species. The historical overview showed a strongly increasing trend in the number of alien species related to an increased amount of intensive research of aquatic vegetation over the last 30 years. Altogether, 20 neophyte alien aquatic plant taxa were recorded from 479 sampling sites. However, the species inventory seems to be far from complete and approximately 14 species are expected to remain undetected. Elodea canadensis and E. nuttallii are the most frequently occurring alien aquatic plants, while eight other species have been found at a single site only. The majority of alien plants were deliberately introduced as aquarium ornamentals or released through pond waste. The fragmented information on local habitat conditions did not allow us to draw firm conclusions about the habitat preferences of alien aquatic plants. However, artificial water bodies are more frequently colonised by alien species than natural habitats (95% of aliens were found in artificial water bodies and 60% of them were recorded exclusively in these habitats) and many species have broad environmental tolerances (ability to colonise both standing and running waters, tolerances to a wide range of temperatures and water chemistry). Our results reaffirm the major role of increased temperatures and landscape modification in the distribution of alien aquatic plants and we can expect enhanced invasiveness and spreading of alien species into new habitats driven by climate change and land use intensification. Filling a main gap in the recognition of alien aquatic plant environmental preferences is a challenge for future research with the ultimate goal of maintaining natural aquatic plant diversity and ecosystem functioning.
invasive species, macrophytes, aquatic weeds, distribution, climate change, land use
Biological invasions by alien plants are generally recognised as an important component of human-induced environmental changes and they have a direct effect on the species diversity of various habitats (
According to the Propagule, Abiotic, Biotic (PAB) framework (
Alien aquatic plants rank amongst the major threats to aquatic biodiversity (e.g. Strayer et al. 2010;
The study covers two important Central European bioregions, the Alpine (Carpathians) and the Pannonian bioregions (Figure
Spatial distribution of alien aquatic plants in Slovakia at the scale of the Central European Flora Mapping System.
The majority of water bodies in Slovakia belong to the catchment basin of the Danube River (Black Sea drainage area), while a small part (the Poprad River) flows to the catchment basin of the Vistula River (Baltic Sea drainage area). The majority of lotic water bodies in Slovakia have been heavily modified in the last century (
We focused on alien aquatic vascular plant species using the definitions of alien species by
We established a database of alien aquatic plants, based on data from the Database of non-native plant species of Slovakia (http://dass.sav.sk/en/) and a checklist of alien flora of Slovakia (
Climate data (mean annual air temperature, January and July mean air temperatures and total annual precipitation) were calculated as mean values for the period 1981–2010. The data were extracted from raster layers provided by the Slovak Hydrometeorological Institute using the GRASS geographic information system (
Composition of landscape was derived from CORINE Land Cover maps (
Water bodies were classified according to their habitat type (lentic, lotic) and origin (natural: rivers, streams, river oxbows, watered terrain depression; artificial: drainage and irrigation canals, water reservoirs, sand or gravel pits). Local characteristics of water bodies, known to affect aquatic plant communities (
For each plant species, the first time of observation (FTO) and the following categories were evaluated: invasion status (IS), cas – casual, nat – naturalised, inv – invasive (
We constructed an analytical sample-based rarefaction curve with unconditional confidence intervals (
We evaluated the effects of climatic characteristics (mean annual air temperature, January and July mean air temperatures and total annual precipitation) and landscape characteristics (cover of road networks, urban areas and natural areas) on the diversity of alien aquatic plants using generalised linear models (GLMs,
Since the majority of records in the database stem from unstructured, opportunistic (presence-only) sampling lacking site-specific environmental information and since many species were found in only a few sites, we did not use inferential statistics to estimate species habitat preferences. Instead, we relied on exploratory data analysis and used a series of bar plots and boxplots to examine the environmental tolerances of alien aquatic plants in Slovakia. In particular, we focused on optima (median) and ranges (min-max) of species with a sufficient number of records.
The analyses were performed in Spade (
Altogether, twenty alien aquatic plant taxa were recorded in Slovakia (Table
All of the recorded aliens belong to neophytes and a substantial proportion has naturalised invasion status (70%) and a deliberate introduction mode (60%) (Table
A Temporal trend in the number of studies involving alien aquatic plants (grey histogram) and cumulative number of alien aquatic plants recorded in Slovakia B Sample-based rarefaction curve of the number of alien aquatic plant species in Slovakia. The grey area represents the 95% confidence band of the diversity estimate. Full list of studies is given in Suppl. material
Species / family | FTO | Source of FTO | IS | RT | IM | WT | GO | CEFMS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alisma subcordatum Raf. / Alismataceae | 2017 | Hrivnák observed & photo | cas | neo | d | Cold | Am | 1 |
Azolla filiculoides Lam. / Salviniaceae | 1951 |
|
nat | neo | a | Cold | Am | 9 |
Egeria densa Planch. / Hydrocharitaceae | 1993 |
|
nat | neo | d | Therm | Am | 1 |
Eichhornia crassipes (Mart.) Solms / Pontederiaceae | 1999 |
|
nat | neo | d | Cold | Am | 7 |
Elodea canadensis Michx. / Hydrocharitaceae | 1883 | Arpád Degen, |
nat | neo | a | Cold | Am | 58 |
Elodea nuttallii (Planch.) H. St. John / Hydrocharitaceae | 1986 | Helena Oťaheľová, |
nat | neo | a | Cold | Am | 42 |
Hydrilla verticillata (L. f.) Royle / Hydrocharitaceae | 1995 |
|
nat | neo | d | Therm | As | 2 |
Lemna minuta Kunth / Lemnaceae | 1997 |
|
nat | neo | a | Cold | Am | 1 |
Lemna turionifera Landolt / Lemnaceae | 2006 | Helena Oťaheľová, CDPR | cas | neo | a | Cold | Am, As | 1 |
Limnophila sessiliflora Blume / Plantaginaceae | 1993 |
|
cas | neo | d | Therm | As | 1 |
Ludwigia repens J. R. Forst. /Onagraceae | 2017 |
|
nat | neo | d | Therm | Am | 1 |
Najas guadalupensis (Spreng.) Magnus / Hydrocharitaceae | 1986 |
|
nat | neo | d | Both | Am, As | 6 |
Nymphaea L. (cultivar) / Nymphaeaceae | 1998 |
|
nat | neo | d | Both | Unk | 17 |
Pistia stratiotes L. / Araceae | 2007 |
|
nat | neo | b | Both | Am | 10 |
Sagittaria latifolia Willd. / Alismataceae Vent. | 2013 |
|
cas | neo | b | Cold | Am | 3 |
Sagittaria subulata (L.) Buchenau / Alismataceae | 1995 |
|
nat | neo | d | Therm | Am | 3 |
Shinnersia rivularis (A. Gray) R. M. King & H. Rob. / Asteraceae | 1998 |
|
nat | neo | d | Therm | Am | 1 |
Utricularia gibba L. / Lentibulariaceae | 1993 |
|
nat | neo | d | Therm | Am, As | 1 |
Vallisneria spiralis L. / Hydrocharitaceae | 2011 | Košťál in |
cas | neo | d | Cold | Af, Am, As | 1 |
Victoria amazonica Sowerby / Nymphaeaceae | 1998 |
|
nat | neo | d | Therm | Am | 2 |
Alien aquatic plants were recorded in 98 grid cells of the CEFMS (~23% of all cells), mainly in the lowlands and valleys of large rivers (Figure
Conwell-Maxwell-Poisson GLM showing a partial relationship between mean annual air temperature, coverage of natural and semi-natural areas and the number of alien aquatic plant species recorded at the scale of the Central European Flora Mapping System with the sampling effort constant at a mean of 4.9 sites. The predicted number of species (line), 95% bootstrap confidence intervals (grey polygon) and partial residuals (points) are displayed.
Results of Conway-Maxwell-Poisson GLMs for the effect of climatic and landscape characteristics on the number of alien aquatic plants in the grid cells of the Central European Flora Mapping System. Standardised regression coefficients (β) and dispersion parameters (ν) are displayed along with their 95% bootstrap confidence intervals (95%CI), test statistics (z, χ2) and probabilities (p). The cross-validated median absolute error of prediction (MdAE) is shown for each model.
Environmental variables | Model coefficients | Dispersion parameters | MdAE | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
β (95%CI) | z | p | ν (95%CI) | χ2 (1) | p | ||
Climate | |||||||
Mean annual temperature | 0.83 (0.39–1.49) | 3.22 | 0.0013 | 6.47 (5.12–9.17) | 83.79 | < 0.0001 | 0.332 |
Mean July temperature | 0.81 (0.36–1.42) | 3.19 | 0.0014 | 6.44 (5.02–9.03) | 83.56 | < 0.0001 | 0.333 |
Mean January temperature | 0.81 (0.37–1.41) | 3.17 | 0.0015 | 6.41 (5.10–9.08) | 83.26 | < 0.0001 | 0.337 |
Annual precipitation | -0.88 (-1.59– -0.45) | -3.32 | 0.0009 | 6.63 (5.29–9.49) | 84.97 | < 0.0001 | 0.381 |
Landscape | |||||||
Road networks | -0.25 (-0.57–0.19) | -0.62 | 0.5360 | 5.57 (4.45–7.92) | 73.86 | < 0.0001 | 0.421 |
Urban areas | 0.44 (-0.10–0.70) | 1.41 | 0.1579 | 5.68 (4.43–7.96) | 75.15 | < 0.0001 | 0.371 |
Natural areas | -0.79 (-1.34– -0.39) | -3.32 | 0.0009 | 6.48 (4.79–9.43) | 84.51 | < 0.0001 | 0.371 |
A comparable number of species was found in cold and thermal waters (Table
Environmental preferences of alien aquatic plants observed in Slovakia. Bar plots display the relative occupancy of water bodies according to the origin (artificial, natural) and habitat type (lotic, lentic). Boxplots show the occurrence of alien aquatic plants along environmental gradients of water temperature, conductivity, pH and water depth. Only species with at least 3 environmental measurements are plotted. Boxplots display median (line), interquartile range (box), range (whiskers) and observed values (jittered points). Full names of taxa are presented in Table
Our review of published and unpublished data revealed the presence of 20 alien aquatic plant species in Slovakia. The number of recorded species has steeply increased with scientific interest in recent decades (Figure
Given the occurrence of many rare species (singletons and doubletons) in Slovakia, the total number of alien aquatic plants is expected to be much higher (Chao2-bc = 34 species) than observed. We may reasonably assume the presence of several aliens, such as Cabomba caroliniana A. Gray, Elodea callitrichoides (Rich.) Casp., Hydrocotyle ranunculoides L. f., Lagarosiphon major (Ridl.) moss or Pontederia cordata L., reported from neighbouring countries. For example, C. caroliniana has been established for a long time in the Pannonian lowlands (
Moreover, a broad number of alien aquatic species, mainly aquarium and ornamental plants, could be added to the list of alien aquatic plants in the future due to their potential release to thermal waters, such as small ponds and fountains in thermal spas, canals with thermal wastewater from spas and swimming pools and/or aquarium waste. The list of these species depends on trade by aquarium and gardening shops. Generally, the pet/aquarium/terrarium trade is responsible for the introduction of numerous alien plants (
Finally, it should be noted that some alien aquatic plants found in Slovakia are considered as invasive alien species of European Union concern (e.g. Eichhornia crassipes, Elodea nuttallii) and they require legislative attention and adequate prevention and management of their introduction and spread on a national level, as stated in EU Regulation no. 1143/2014.
We have shown that the diversity of alien aquatic plants is significantly linked with climatic conditions. In particular, the number of species increases along gradients of increasing air temperatures and decreasing precipitations. The geographic ranges of many alien aquatic plant species are strongly associated with climatic tolerances set by air temperatures (
The role of precipitation is less obvious since temperature characteristics and precipitation were strongly correlated in the studied area (Pearson r = -0.78 – -0.87). However, if we combined temperatures and precipitation in a single model or if we used some compound measures, such as climatic moisture index (
Our results also revealed that landscape with a higher proportion of natural and semi-natural areas supports lower diversity of aliens than intensively managed land. However, we have also shown that plain habitat accessibility to humans, as vectors of dispersal, is not sufficient to explain diversity patterns of aliens, since neither road network coverage nor the proportion of urban areas alone were significantly related with the alien species diversity. Human-mediated landscape effects are likely more complex, involving both accessibility and intensive land use. For example, extensive agricultural cultivation, associated with irrigation channels and elevated nutrient levels, may facilitate dispersal and establishment of alien aquatic plant populations (
In conclusion, our results reaffirmed the major role of climate and landscape modification in the distribution of alien aquatic plants. We may reasonably expect further increases in alien numbers under ongoing global climate change and land use intensification, especially in the lowlands of southern and eastern Slovakia. Moreover, since elevated temperatures and CO2 levels are assumed to increase the performance of alien plants more steeply than that of native species (
The lack of detailed information on local environmental conditions hampered our ability to draw broad conclusions about the habitat preferences of alien aquatic plant species in Slovakia. However, a few consistent patterns emerged. First, artificial water bodies were more often colonised by alien species than natural habitats and the majority of the species were found exclusively in man-made water bodies. Indeed, this seemingly higher preference of alien species for artificial habitats may partly stem from the fact that many (sub)tropical species are inevitably present only in artificial water bodies with thermal water (e.g. wastewater canals from thermal spas). However, our observations are in agreement with the patterns recorded in the terrestrial realm, where heavily modified and man-made habitats rank amongst the most invaded biotopes in Europe (
Second, species with available environmental information showed relatively wide environmental tolerances (Figure
Finally, our research revealed a serious gap in knowledge of alien aquatic plant habitat requirements; only a few species have sufficient records of local habitat quality necessary for sound examination of environmental niches. Therefore, further research should focus on estimating environmental niche breadths and subsequently identifying the potential invasiveness of alien aquatic plants.
Based on a thorough review of published and unpublished resources, 20 alien aquatic species were recorded in Slovakia. However, the presence of many other alien species might be reasonably expected considering (i) a high proportion of rare species (low detectability), (ii) the deliberate introduction of aquarium and ornamental plants and (iii) the positive effect of rising temperatures and intensively modified landscape on alien species diversity. Given ongoing climate change and land use intensification, one can reasonably assume enhanced invasiveness and spreading of alien species into new habitats.
Filling a gap in the recognition of alien aquatic plant environmental tolerances is a challenge for future research. There is also an urgent need for studies on population dynamics, reproductive output, seed-bank characteristics and functional traits of alien aquatic vascular plants, as well as their competitive ability and their interactions with native biota in freshwaters. Finally, raising public awareness and developing adequate management strategies are ultimate conservation goals for maintaining natural aquatic plant diversity and ecosystem functioning.
We would like to thank D. Senko for preparing the climatic data and J. Kochjarová for help in the field. This work was supported by the Slovak Research and Development Agency under Contract No. APVV-16-0236 (RH, MS). MS was also supported by the European Regional Development Fund-Project “Mechanisms and dynamics of macromolecular complexes: from single molecules to cells” (No. CZ.02.1.01/0.0/0.0/15_003/0000441).
List of references used for the preparation of a database of alien aquatic plants in Slovakia
Data type: references data