Research Article |
Corresponding author: Christine Ewers-Saucedo ( ewers-saucedo@zoolmuseum.uni-kiel.de ) Academic editor: Adam Petrusek
© 2022 Lena Homberger, Jiawu Xu, Dirk Brandis, Tin-Yam Chan, Heleen Keirsebelik, Monika Normant-Saremba, Jonas Schoelynck, Ka Hou Chu, Christine Ewers-Saucedo.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Homberger L, Xu J, Brandis D, Chan T-Y, Keirsebelik H, Normant-Saremba M, Schoelynck J, Chu KH, Ewers-Saucedo C (2022) Genetic and morphological evidence indicates the persistence of Japanese mitten crab mitochondrial DNA in Europe for over 20 years and its introgression into Chinese mitten crabs. NeoBiota 73: 137-152. https://doi.org/10.3897/neobiota.73.72566
|
Cryptic biological invasions are largely unrecognised, leading to an underestimation of the number of invading taxa and their potential impacts. The Chinese mitten crab, Eriocheir sinensis, is a highly invasive species with serious economic and ecological impacts in Europe. Recently, mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) of the Japanese mitten crab, E. japonica, has been discovered in populations from The Netherlands, Poland and Germany, but the taxonomic status and time of introduction of specimens carrying this mtDNA are uncertain. To this end, we investigated the morphology and variation of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) gene of mitten crabs collected in central-western Europe between 1998 and 2020. Mitten crabs from Belgium harboured a Japanese mitten crab COI haplotype in 33% to 65% of individuals, even in our earliest samples from 1998. All other studied populations carried only Chinese mitten crab COI haplotypes. Morphologically, many of the juvenile Belgian mitten crabs showed intermediate traits between the two species, while all investigated adult mitten crabs, regardless of their mitochondrial haplotype or country of origin, were morphologically assigned to E. sinensis. This intermediate morphology of the juveniles and genetic-morphological discrepancy of adults suggests that Japanese mitten crabs introgressed with Chinese mitten crabs, which could have happened both before and after the introduction of mitten crabs to Europe. A specific Chinese mitten crab COI haplotype, found in Belgium, was previously only known from Vladivostok (Russia), where Chinese and Japanese mitten crab hybrids naturally occur. This Far East region is, therefore, a plausible source for at least part of the mitten crab mitochondrial diversity in Belgium.
Belgium, introgression, mitochondrial DNA, mitten crab, morphometrics, museum collections
Global expansion in travel and trade has greatly increased the number of invasive species (
In a global assessment of mitten crab diversity,
A total of 141 mitten crabs were collected for morphological and genetic assessment by local fishermen or hand-caught between 1998 and 2020: 65 crabs from the Rivers Eider, Elbe, Weser and the Kiel Canal in northern Germany, 20 crabs from the Vistula Lagoon in Poland and 56 crabs from Oostende (North Sea) and the Schelde River Basin in Belgium (Table
Country | Sampling location | GPS coordinates | Sampling dates | No. individuals | Sampling site ID | Catalogue no. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Germany | Geesthacht (Elbe River) | 53.4261°N, 10.3710°E | 23.10.2009 | 9 | EL09 | Cr 3207, Cr 3209 |
2019–2020 | 10 | EL20 | Cr 3687 | |||
Horst (Eider River) | 54.3160°N, 9.1901°E | 30.11.2009 | 2 | EI09 | Cr 3222 | |
30.4.2020 | 5 | EI20 | Cr 3688 | |||
Kiel (Kiel Canal, Kiel Fjord) | 54.328751°N–54.3727°N, 9.9641°E–10.1496°E | 2008–2009 | 8 | KF09 | Cr 3224, Cr 3227, Cr 3201, Cr 3216 | |
54.3410°N–54.3699°N, 9.7349°E–10.1389°E | 2019–2020 | 21 | KF20 | Cr 3689, Cr 3690 | ||
Bünzau (Aukrug) | 54.0890°N, 9.7970°E | 31.07.2008 | 1 | AU08 | Cr 3215 | |
Thedinghausen (Weser River) | 52.9828°N–52.9819°N, 9.0272°E–9.0436°E | 2019 | 9 | WE19 | Cr 3514, Cr 3515, Cr 3516, Cr 3517, Cr 3518 | |
Poland | Vistula Lagoon | 54.4657°N, 19.7574°E | 10.2020 | 20 | PO20 | NA |
Belgium | Oostende (North Sea) | 51.2281°N, 2.9509°E | 08.1998 | 6 | BE98 | NTOU B00134 |
08.2005 | 10 | BE05 | NTOU B00133 | |||
Grobbendonk (Kleine Nete River, Greater Schelde River Basin) | 51.1802°N, 4.7390°E | 2018–2020 | 34 | BE20 | NA | |
Doel (Schelde River) | 51.3162°N, 4.2676°E | 02.09.2020 | 3 | BE20 | NA | |
Bergenmeersen (Schelde River) | 51.02211°N, 3.9645°E | 20.10.2020 | 3 | BE20 | NA |
We extracted genomic DNA from about 1 mm3 of pereopod muscle tissue with the Chelex method (
For the morphological assessment, we evaluated four presumably species-specific characteristics of the carapace in juvenile and adult mitten crabs that were genotyped at the COI locus: the ratio of carapace width to length, the shape of the infraorbital region, the epi-and protogastric crest and the markedness of the fourth lateral tooth, which were scored as either E. sinensis-like or E. japonica-like (
Selected species-specific carapace characteristics distinguishing Eriocheir sinensis and Eriocheir japonica according to
Trait | Eriocheir sinensis | Eriocheir japonica |
---|---|---|
Infraorbital region | With four distinct teeth | Granulated, 4-lobed, separated medially by shallow sinus |
4th lateral tooth of carapace | Present | Small or rudimentary, sometimes reduced to a granule |
Carapace width : carapace length ratio | 1.08 (relatively smaller) | 1.12 (relatively larger) |
Epi- and protogastric crest | Very strong, high and sharp | Low, weak, blunt |
Carapace morphology of the mitten crab species Eriocheir sinensis (A, C) and E. japonica (B, D). Line drawings (A, B) are reproduced from
We conducted a morphometric analysis, based on 27 landmarks (Fig.
A total of 141 specimens were newly sequenced at the COI locus in our study (Table
Haplotype network of all analysed sequences from the introduced European range. Each circle represents one haplotype. Size of the circles is proportional to the number of individuals carrying the respective haplotype. Colours denote the sampling locality. The haplotypes were named following
In total, 38 specimens carried a single E. japonica haplotype (Fig.
Geographic distribution of COI haplotypes of E. sinensis and E. japonica in the studied region of Europe, based on newly-generated and publicly-available sequence data A the WE (Weser River), EL (Elbe River) and LA (Laascher Lake) populations were sampled by
All the 41 investigated adult mitten crabs from Belgium, Germany and Poland with a carapace width from 44 to 96 mm were morphologically identified as E. sinensis: they had four distinct infraorbital teeth, the fourth lateral spine was pointing outwards, the epi- and protogastric crest was very strong and the carapace length to width ratio was between 1.019 and 1.158 (Suppl. material
The 35 examined juvenile crabs from Belgium and Germany were morphologically more variable (Fig.
Morphological differentiation amongst juvenile mitten crabs from Germany and Belgium A juvenile crab from Germany (ID: KC20-02, collected in the Kiel Canal in 2020, E. sinensis mtDNA) with a toothed infraorbital region (brackets) and pointed fourth lateral tooth (arrow) B juvenile crab from Belgium (ID: BE20-05, collected in Belgium in 2020, E. japonica mtDNA) with a lobed infraorbital region and inconspicuous fourth lateral tooth. Scale bars indicate 1 cm. Distribution of morphological characteristics of infraorbital region C and fourth lateral tooth D in respect to mtDNA and origin of individuals. Significant differences between groups are marked by asterisks. Purple colour indicates Japanese mitten crab character states and mtDNA and blue colour indicates Chinese mitten crab character states and mtDNA.
The infraorbital teeth of the juvenile German E. sinensis crabs were sharply pointed in all but one individual (ID: KC09-90, Fig.
Similarly, the fourth lateral spines pointed outwards in all German individuals, but were less conspicuous in 55% (13 out of 28) of the Belgian individuals (Fig.
The geometric morphometric analysis was conducted on 69 specimens with a carapace width between 15 and 96 mm. Of these specimens, 29 were from Belgium, 27 from Germany and 10 from Poland. In addition, we included three specimens from the native range, two E. sinensis from the Yangtze River in China and one E. japonica from Shimonoseki in Japan (Fig.
Geometric morphometric analysis on the carapace of mitten crabs from Belgium, Germany and Poland and three native specimens from China and Japan A procrustes shapes of two specimens at the opposite ends of the first principal component axis B scatterplot of the first two axes of the principal component analysis. Each dot is a specimen, with size proportional to carapace width. Colours denote different sampling countries and asterisks individuals with an E. japonica haplotype.
While the PCA does not indicate strong clustering by country, the analysis of variance gave significant results for both carapace width (p-value = 0.001) and locality (p-value = 0.001), but not for their interaction (p-value = 0.12) or mtDNA lineage (E. sinensis vs. E. japonica) (p-value = 0.16). These results remained the same after removing the native-range specimens from the analysis. The mitten crabs from Belgium, Germany and Poland clustered with the two Chinese mitten crabs from the native range. In the PCA, the Belgian juveniles (about half of which carried E. japonica mtDNA) were somewhat distinct from the German juveniles, for which the sample size was small (n = 7).
Our study indicates the presence of Japanese mitten crab mtDNA in Belgium since at least 1998, possibly even earlier. Morphologically, however, all adult crabs are identified as Chinese mitten crabs, which explains why the presence of the genetic footprint of Japanese mitten crabs remained overlooked until the employment of molecular analysis. The juvenile crabs from Belgium showed morphological subtle differences to juveniles from Germany, but these differences do not match with the assignment, based on COI haplotypes. This mismatch between morphology and mtDNA implies introgression with a mostly E. sinensis nuclear genome, assuming that morphology reflects the nuclear genome well. The increase of E. japonica mtDNA from 33% to 65% from 1998 to 2020, observed in Belgian mitten crabs, indicates that this haplotype has become established in Europe and may become more abundant in the region. It likely became established also in the neighbouring Netherlands because the same Japanese mitten crab COI haplotype was found in three out of four mitten crabs collected there in 2011 (
Many of the Belgian juveniles show morphological characteristics of E. japonica, while most juvenile mitten crabs from Germany show the characteristics of E. sinensis. As we did not find the E. japonica haplotype in any specimens from Germany or Poland, these populations may not have introgressed, suggesting that juveniles with more or less “pure” E. sinensis genomes may differ morphologically from juveniles with an introgressed genomic background. The PCA of the morphometric data also suggests that the morphological differentiation is more pronounced in juveniles. This proposed introgression could have occurred either in the native range, prior to their introduction, or after the introduction of “pure” parental Japanese mitten crabs to Belgium, where Chinese mitten crabs have been present since the 1930s. In support of the first hypothesis, a native hybrid zone exists at the northern limit of the two species’ distribution around Vladivostok in Russia and northern China (
The region around Vladivostok is a plausible source of the introduction of individuals carrying E. japonica mtDNA to Europe, whether pure or hybrid. We identified two individuals from Belgium with the E. sinensis haplotype H18 previously only detected in Vladivostok where 3 out of 10 specimens carried this haplotype (
Interestingly, each of the three European countries shows different temporal dynamics of COI haplotypes. In Belgium, the Japanese mitten crab COI haplotype seems to be increasing over time, though sample sizes are too small to confirm this increase statistically. In northern Germany, the same Chinese mitten crab haplotypes have been present in the past 23 years and the Japanese mitten crab haplotype has never been recorded. In Poland, on the other hand, the specimens sampled in 2020 had a different haplotype distribution to the specimens sampled in 2015. Mitten crabs do not form an established population in Poland where salinity is too low for larval development (
Eriocheir japonica has a similar life history to E. sinensis with planktonic larvae and migrating adults, such that similar expansion rates may be assumed (
Another possible interpretation is that the Belgian population with their introgressed Japanese mitten crab mtDNA has a lower invasive potential. Where the Japanese mitten crab itself has been reported outside its native range, for example, on the west coast of North America (
There is evidence that the invasion process of mitten crabs is ongoing (
We are indebted to C. d’Udekem d’Acoz and J. Mares for collecting the Eriocheir specimens from Belgium in 1998 and 2005 and for providing information on the history of mitten crab introduction in Belgium. We appreciate the help of the fishermen Eckhard Panz, Jörg von der Heyde, Thomas Philipson and Anton Kardel in supplying mitten crabs from Germany and Paul van Loon (Flemish Environmental Agency) for the crabs of Grobbendonk (Belgium). This work was supported by research grants from the Research Grants Council, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China (Project no. 4162/99M, to KHC), the Ministry of Science and Technology, Taiwan and the Center of Excellence for the Oceans, National Taiwan Ocean University (to TYC), University of Antwerp Bijzonder Onderzoeksfonds (to JS and HK, Project no. 44158), European Union’s funding Programme Interreg Baltic Sea Region in 2017–2020 (European Regional Development Fund) (project COMPLETE – Completing management options in the Baltic Sea region to reduce risk of invasive species introduction by shipping, to MNS), Polish Ministry of Education and Science financial resources for science in the years 2017–2020 (grant No. 3859/INTERREG BSR/17/2018 for an International co-financed project, to MNS), and the German Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) (grant no. 01UQ1711 “MARSAMM”, to DB). We appreciate the thoughtful comments of the editor Adam Petrusek and an anonymous reviewer, which improved the manuscript substantially.
Table S1. Master spreadsheet with morphological and genetic information for each specimen
Data type: Morphological.